We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Updated onApr. 25, 2022

Best Gutter Guards

Gutter guards may not seem like a high priority for seniors aging in place, but they’re a simple improvement to your house that can help you handle your home maintenance easier as you become less inclined to perform the maintenance yourself.

With a gutter guard, debris like leaves are less likely to fall into your gutters, so rainwater can flow through appropriately without getting clogged up on your roof. Furthermore, gutter guards can help prevent ice dams in the winter, which can cause extensive roof damage and moisture inside the house.

When your gutters are working properly, you have less maintenance to perform and won’t have to worry about cleaning them out. Furthermore, aging in place means your home should be as comfortable and safe as possible, and you don’t need to worry about having to make extensive repairs that stem from clogged gutters. If your gutters become clogged and lead to moisture inside your home, you could also be prone to accidents like slips and falls.

Find the best gutter guards for your home and needs so you don’t need to worry about repairs and home maintenance.

How We Found the Best Gutter Guards

8 Reviewers
50 Products Considered
12 Hours of Research
7 Products Reviewed
3 Top Picks
Best Foam

Best Foam

GutterStuff EZ 5-Inch K Style Gutter Guard, 8 Piece x 4 Feet
$78.21

We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Features and Specifications

  • GutterStuff EZ is an easy, self-installed gutter guard that is both affordable and invisible and eliminates dangerous and dirty gutter cleaning. GutterStuff EZ seals out leaves and allows large volumes of water to flow through quickly. No other gutter…
  • Keep your gutters clean with GutterStuff.
  • Easiest DIY gutter filter on the market.
  • No Tools Required!
  • Affordable protection – invisible from below. Fits K-Style Gutters
Pros
  • They are lightweight and easy to handle.

  • They are a breeze to install.

  • They come with a three-year warranty.

  • The colors blend in well and are not obtrusive.

Cons
  • While useful for larger particles, smaller ones will clog them over time and leave a layer of sludge in your gutters.

  • Will need to be replaced over time.

The GutterStuff EZ 5-Inch K Style Foam Gutter Filter Insert offers a simple solution to a vexing problem. These gutter guards come in multiple sizes and lengths. They differ from similar products in that they fit inside your gutters, so they’ll keep out debris but allow water to pass through them. They also help prevent mosquitoes from getting out of hand by eliminating a place for them to breed.

The inserts are durable and will last for a long time. They can withstand direct sunlight and won’t dry out or fall apart. The construction also includes a germicide to prevent bacteria growth since gutters would be a likely place for it to develop. We also liked the fact that they are lightweight, which makes them very easy to install for seniors, especially if you live alone and would like to care of it yourself. However, keep in mind that you shouldn’t go on a ladder unless someone is available to make sure it is stabilized.

If you are looking to reduce as much home maintenance as possible, these may not be the best option for you. Though they last long, they will still need to be replaced eventually, so a more permanent option could be better for some seniors.

Our Verdict

They offer an affordable way to keep your gutters debris-free.

Best Aluminum

Best Aluminum

FlexxPoint 30 Year Gutter Cover System, Residential 5″ Gutter Guards, 102ft
$134.00

We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Features and Specifications

  • Available in White, Matte Aluminum, Thermal Thaw Black and Brown. Now made from Fully Hardened High Strength .019 Heavy Gauge Aluminum!
  • Easy to Install, Contractor pricing, Includes 1/2″ #8 Stainless Steel Zip Screws.
  • Cannot be seen from the ground, Blocks all types of debris. Clog free, High volume water flow.
  • Does NOT void roof warranties, Permanently installs, Easy to handle 4 foot sections
  • Now with STAINLESS STEEL fastners, Factory Direct, Made in the USA
Pros
  • The black covers are an excellent way to prevent ice dams.

  • They offer a permanent solution.

  • They are made in the United States.

  • They allow for ample air and water flow.

  • They are made of lightweight aluminum.

Cons
  • You’ll still need to clean off the top periodically.

  • You’ll still need to clean off the top periodically.

The FlexxPoint 30 Year Gutter Cover System offers a simple fix with perforated covers that keep out leaves and other debris. They allow for ample water flow because of the dense pattern of holes. Don’t let the long lengths deter you. They come in 4-foot sections that make installation easier. Like the previous foam gutter guards that we mentioned, you won’t see them from the ground.

These gutter guards provide permanent protection, so you won’t need to worry about constant maintenance or replacements except for the standard gutter check you may perform annually. The aluminum material is weather-proof and means these gutter guards will last for a long time to come.

In terms of installation, you will need some tools to install them, so you may need to hire someone to get the job done. You also have your choice of colors if you decide to go with these gutter guards. If you live in colder climates, you have the option to get black ones that can help retain heat and prevent ice from forming.

Our Verdict

They provide an excellent weather-proof way to keep debris out of your gutters.

Best Mesh

Best Mesh

E-Z-GUTTER GUARD EZ-Quick-10 Gutter Guard, Silver
$60.61

We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Features and Specifications

  • Includes ten 4-foot sections – entire box installed covers 39. 2 feet; Each section notched for ¾-inch in overlap
  • Easy to install – no screws needed; snaps out for maintenance
  • Heavy-duty expanded aluminum won’t rust or rot
  • Not designed for plastic gutter; fits only 5” residential K-style gutter with hidden hangers
  • Tight mesh keeps debris out while letting rainwater rush through; Pine needles and other very small debris may pass thru screen; E-Z-Shield should be used in areas where this may occur
Pros
  • They are lightweight and easy to handle.

  • The manufacturer is USA-based.

  • They are weather-resistant and won’t rust.

  • You can remove them without trouble if need be.

  • You can cut them to size.

Cons
  • Ice will form over them during the winter months.

  • Pricey if you need two packages

The Mesh E-Z Gutter Guard offers all the convenient installation like that of a foam gutter guard, with more of the permanence of an aluminum mesh.

These mesh guards come in 4-foot sections, so they’re easy to handle, and each section doesn’t weigh much more than three pounds.   You don’t need any tools to install them, which makes them a possible DIY project. Instead, they snap into place easily. The mesh is light and fine enough to keep out debris while still allowing water and air to flow freely. If you live in colder climates, however, these gutter guards may not be the best option since it is possible for ice to freeze on top and cause the same problems that ice dams would cause without gutter guards.

Since the material is so light, you can also cut them to whatever length you need. Our one gripe is that the available product goes from 40 to 80 feet when you buy two packages. One is affordable, but buying a second one to cover an additional 10 feet is expensive. We’d prefer a shorter length to make the purchase more reasonable.

Our Verdict

They are lightweight, making installation easy.

Best Leaf Guards

Best Leaf Guards

Gutter Guard 3 Inch Expand Aluminum Filter Strainer. Stops Blockage Leaves Debris. Pack of 4. by Massca (Aluminum 3 inch)
$12.99

We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Features and Specifications

  • Save Your Precious Time & Effort – Sick and tired of constantly having to unclog your gutters and downspouts? With the heavy-duty gutter guards you now make sure that your gutters and down pipes are protected from leaf debris, roof moss, twigs and…
  • Install Them In Seconds – Unlike other impractical gutter filters, the Massca downpipe leaf guards can be installed in seconds without using any tools. You don’t have to be an expert or call a professional. Simply push them into place and you’re…
  • Heavy -Duty Construction – Made of non-corrosive, weatherproof and waterproof aluminum, our robust gutter guards will pass the test of time. Rest assured that they will stay firmly in place no matter the weather conditions and you’ll not have to climb…
  • A Must-Have for Every Guttering System– By preventing leaf debris, twigs, roof moss and dirt from clogging your pipes, you can easily make sure that your guttering system stays in perfect condition for longer without the need for costly repairs and…
  • 100% Satisfaction or Your Money Back – You can try our 4-pack of sturdy downpipe gutter filters for 30 days absolutely risk-free and if by that time you’re not 100% thrilled with their performance, we promise to offer you a prompt and full refund….
Pros
  • They are inexpensive.

  • They come with a satisfaction guarantee.

  • They are weather-resistant.

  • They are durable.

  • They stay put once you install them.

Cons
  • They offer no protection against ice dams.

  • You’ll still need to perform regular maintenance on your gutters.

The Massca Gutter Guard is a good option if your main problem is with leaves clogging your downward spout. This guard works by snapping into place directly above the downward spout in your gutter so that water can still flow through freely without getting clogged on the way down.

The caps are easy to snap into place and don’t require any tools, so they’re an excellent option for budget-minded individuals who are also capable of installing themselves. They are easily removable as well if you need to take them off anytime. The inserts are well-made and can handle the elements well, so they’ll typically last a long time. However, this option may not be great if you’re aging in place with limited mobility and are looking for a solution that takes care of maintenance as well. With these gutter guards, leaves will still get stuck in your gutters, so you will need to clean them out over time. Especially if you live in colder climates, ice dams will still be likely to form with these guards in place.

We liked the fact that they are small and pliable enough to mold into shape as needed. While the mesh works for larger debris, pine needles will still get through and into the downspouts. You can use them on structures with diameters of 2 to 3 inches.

Our Verdict

They keep your downspouts clear of larger debris.

We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Features and Specifications

  • 4-PACK: Secures in downspout but unlike filters and strainers, works toward removing leaf build-up through its Wedge design – allows leaves to push up, dry off and blow out of the gutters!
  • The Wedge Downspout Gutter Guard Fits All 2 in by 3 in Standard Downspouts, and fits best in standard 5″ gutters (most common)
  • Easy To Install; No Tools Needed; Keep Gutters Flowing – Eliminates Messy Clogging By Directing Leaves and Debris Away From Downspout Openings
  • Connectors Included To Connect Wedges Together For Downspouts Located Away From Corners of a Home; Arrives flat but assembles in minutes with no tools required! Made in U.S.A
  • The Variation is for 5″ Gutters with 2″ by 3″ Downspouts. For 6″ gutters, search for item: B08FCPGKVX
Pros
  • They are affordable.

  • They are easy to install.

  • They are made in the USA.

  • They are weather-resistant.

  • The screen keeps smaller debris out of your downspouts.

Cons
  • The plastic material is cheap and won’t last very long

  • The plastic material is cheap and won’t last very long

The Wedge Downspout Gutter Guard differs from other products in that they are wedge-shaped to help facilitate water flow. They’ll fit any standard-sized downspout. Like the Massca Gutter Guard, they are a breeze to install without special tools, but they’re  only purpose is to prevent leaves from clogging downspouts.

The gutter guards are made of plastic, which cuts down on the cost. You’ll also get four to a pack, which makes them a decent value. If you’re looking for value, these truly are the best option, but they won’t help with mitigating gutter maintenance. The plastic material may not last long as other options, and the design will still allow for leaves to fall into your gutters, causing them to need to be cleaned regularly. If you have the ability to still perform maintenance, however, these are a great option to ensure your gutters operate properly and you won’t need to worry about huge repairs to your roof or home.

Our Verdict

They are an affordable solution that works.

Best Leaf Filters

Best Leaf Filters

LeafsOut 5” WIDE, DIY Micro Mesh Rain Gutter Guard System – 100′ LONG, Stainless Steel
Price not available

We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Features and Specifications

Pros
  • While flexible to fit most gutters, you can order a sample to make sure that it’ll work for you.

  • They are weather and UV-resistant.

  • The mesh is fine enough to keep most anything out of your gutters.

  • They offer a permanent solution.

  • They are well-constructed.

Cons
  • They are expensive.

  • Heavy rainfall or snowmelt may bypass the screen.

The LeafsOut 5” WIDE, DIY Micro Mesh Rain Gutter Guard System is a stainless steel mesh that covers the top of your gutters to keep debris and other materials from clogging them. Unlike the other products we’ve reviewed, this one slips under the roof to secure it into place. That may be problematic in some situations since the installation isn’t as straightforward. If you’re aging in place on your own and don’t want to hire professional help, this may not be the best option for you.

The mesh does a decent job of keeping out debris, including finer materials such as pine needles. You can rest assured that your gutters will not be clogged with any type of debris. However, if you live in colder climates that get a lot of rain and snow fall in the winter, ice may still form on top of the guards.

Although these guards are more difficult to install, they offer a great permanent solution to help mitigate gutter maintenance and any home repairs associated with clogged gutters. The material is built to be durable against sunlight, rain, snow, and variable temperatures, so they’ll last for years to come. Furthermore, the installation locks the guards in place so you won’t need to move or change them out.

Our Verdict

They will keep leaves out of your gutter but may not work well during heavy rainfall.

Best Easy Installation

Best Easy Installation

E-Z-GUTTER GUARD EZ-Shield-10 Gutter Guard, Black
$73.02

We may receive a commission if you click certain product links below. This helps support our independent testing and research to provide free, unbiased product and service reviews for our readers. Learn More about our ad policies.

Features and Specifications

  • Designed for 5″ residential gutters; Easy to install – no screws needed; Each section notched for 3/4 inch in overlap
  • Heavy-duty painted aluminum won’t rust or rot; Black color blends with roofline and heats quickly to melt ice and snow
  • Designed to stay in place during rough weather; Snaps out for maintenance ; It’s a snap to install — no screws needed
  • Reverse louvers allow maximum water through but keep debris out
  • Includes ten 4-foot sections; Entire box installed covers 40 feet; Made in U. S. A.
Pros
  • The black color facilitates ice and snow melt.

  • They are lightweight.

  • They are sturdy and well-made.

Cons
  • While they work for pine needles, smaller seeds might get through and clog your gutters.

  • They aren’t a fully permanent solution

This aluminum E-Z Gutter Guard is designed to be both easy to install and long lasting. The heavy-duty aluminum is protected against rut and rot, but it’s also designed to be lightweight at less than six pounds. If you live in colder climates, the material is also a great choice to help maximize sunlight and prevent ice dams from water running underneath the guard.

We feel this is a great option for seniors who need a gutter guard that is easy to install, but would also like to reduce the amount of maintenance they perform on their gutters. They strike a welcome balance between putting up a barrier to debris and allowing water to flow freely. However, keep in mind that these gutters aren’t as permanent of an option as others, and you may need to replace them eventually.

The guards are pliable. You can also cut them to size without much trouble. Water flow is adequate but not the best. You may still need to clean off the top of them occasionally to ensure that it doesn’t stop altogether. And as with similar products, heavy rainfalls will test the viability of the guards.

Our Verdict

The black color cuts down on ice dam formation and is easy to install for seniors.

Now that you’ve seen some of the options you have, let’s discuss the different points to factor into your choice of a product. The best gutter guards work as described and add a measure of safety to the area around your house. Items that cut down on gutter maintenance scored high marks with us.

Choosing the right foldable cane seat is an important decision because it is something that you should be able to use for a while.

Now that you’ve seen what options you have let’s discuss the points to factor into your choice of a product. The best gutter guards work as described and add a measure of safety to the area around your house. Items that cut down on our maintenance scored high marks with us. Listed below are the major categories to consider when purchasing a gutter guard for you or a loved ones home.

Type

The manufacturers of gutter guards tackle the problem of clogged gutters in several ways. A popular option is a screen or some type of mesh that you place over them. This idea works in principle. However, it doesn’t eliminate the need to clean them. You’ll still have to attend to the filter to make sure that a film doesn’t form over them and impedes water flow. There are also foam options that help completely block out debris while still promoting water flow. However, these tend to need to be replaced more often than others.

Other types of guards fit into the top of your downspouts. They are an affordable option if you live someplace where snow on your roof isn’t an issue. In either case, we strongly urge you to check the gauge of the mesh to make sure it will work for you.

Water And Air Flow

This criterion is probably the most critical factor to consider. It’s essential on several scores. Water that collects in your gutters creates the ideal environment for mosquitoes, flies, and other pests. If the mesh is too fine, water may not filter through the guard and flow over instead. That can lead to icicle and ice dam formation, which cause roof and home damage that lead to leaks, slips and falls.

We recommend checking out the manufacturer’s guarantee and warranty before you buy. And don’t hesitate to return them if they aren’t doing the job as you expect. Remember that the purpose of gutter guards is to reduce your maintenance while avoiding the creation of a hazard.

Installation

Be sure to take a moment to review what’s involved with installation. Many products make it an easy task without the need for power equipment or tools. However, it can take more work with some items, requiring you to hire someone. Take that cost into account to avoid any nasty surprises, which is particularly crucial if you are on a fixed income. You’ll also need to consider your mobility and ability to use a ladder yourself. It isn’t necessary to try to install a gutter guard if you think it could be dangerous, and it’s best to take the cautious route and ask someone for help.

We’d also suggest contacting your homeowners’ association if necessary. And if you’ve had a roof installed recently, make sure that the gutter guards don’t void your warranty. That is typically a problem if you need to slide something underneath the shingles or shakes. Many manufacturers will point out this information in their product descriptions.

Finally, bear in mind that these items will not replace regular maintenance but instead cut down the frequency. Some still require routine cleaning to ensure adequate water and air flow too. However, we find that task easier than removing leaves and less messy.

Gutter guards offer an excellent way to keep your gutters clear of debris while cutting down on your yearly maintenance. The prices of most products are reasonable and installation can be easy to handle on your own, so it’s worth the investment. To choose the best gutter guard for your home, consider your lifestyle, budget, and expected mobility within the next several years. Cutting down on your gutter maintenance can help relieve some stress related with aging in place and completing home maintenance, while gutter guards will also prevent big problems like roof damage, which can be costly and dangerous for seniors at home.